If you're a college basketball fan and the name UMBC doesn't give you chills, you haven't been paying attention. On March 16, 2018, the Retrievers became the first and only 16-seed to defeat a 1-seed in NCAA Tournament history, destroying Tony Bennett's Virginia Cavaliers 74-54 in what remains the single most shocking upset the tournament has ever produced. Jairus Lyles poured in 28 points that night, and a tiny commuter school in suburban Baltimore became a household name overnight. Now, eight years later, UMBC is back. They're riding a 12-game winning streak, they won the America East tournament convincingly, and they've got a 24-8 record that demands respect. This isn't a feel-good story about a cute little mid-major. This is a legitimately good basketball team.
The Retrievers are led by DJ Armstrong Jr., who was named America East Tournament Most Outstanding Player after dropping a career-high 33 points on 9-of-11 shooting in the conference championship game, including a blistering 7-of-9 from beyond the arc. Armstrong went 7-of-9 from beyond the arc in that championship game, and when he gets hot from deep, good luck slowing him down. Jah'Likai King earned First Team All-Conference honors as the team's leading scorer, while Ace Valentine added a Second Team All-Conference nod and provides a steady secondary scoring punch. In the paint, Jose Roberto Tanchyn and Josh Odunowo have transformed UMBC's interior defense since Tanchyn entered the starting lineup. Over the last 11 games, the Retrievers have allowed just a 22.8% rim rate, which ranks in the 98th percentile nationally. Head coach Jim Ferry has this team playing elite defense, averaging just 67.0 points allowed per game, which ranks 29th in the country. UMBC also commits the second-fewest fouls in the nation at 13.3 per game, meaning they rarely put opponents on the free throw line.
Howard has their own impressive story. The Bison won the MEAC regular season title and then claimed the conference tournament championship with a 70-63 win over North Carolina Central, finishing the year at 23-10. They're on an eight-game winning streak of their own and come into Dayton with serious momentum. MEAC Player of the Year Bryce Harris leads the way at 17.1 points per game, and he's flanked by Defensive Player of the Year Cedric Taylor III, who nearly matches Harris's production with a similar stat line of about 17 points and 7 rebounds per game. Point guard Cam Gillus is the engine that makes it all go, averaging 10.6 points while ranking third in the MEAC in both assists (4.6 per game) and steals (1.8 per game). All three made the MEAC All-Tournament team. The Bison also force turnovers at an elite rate, ranking 10th nationally with over 15 per game, and they've gone 7-2 against the spread as underdogs this season while winning all five of their neutral-site games.
Here's where it gets interesting from an analytical standpoint. UMBC holds a significant offensive efficiency advantage, ranking roughly 100 spots higher than Howard on KenPom in that category. But Howard flips the script defensively, holding nearly the same margin in defensive efficiency. Both teams played incredibly soft schedules during the regular season, but Howard at least tested themselves against Duke and Missouri in non-conference play. UMBC's 22 wins this season were all Quad 4 victories, and the Retrievers went 0-5 in Quad 1-3 games. That's the kind of stat that makes you pump the brakes on their winning streak, even if the eye test says they're playing terrific basketball right now.
The total of 140.5 tells you the market expects this to be a grind. Both defenses are stingy, and the neutral-site First Four environment often produces tighter, more cautious basketball as teams feel out the magnitude of the moment. The winner gets the dubious honor of facing Michigan, the number one seed in the Midwest, on Thursday in Buffalo. It's a near-impossible ask for either of these teams, but hey, UMBC already pulled off the impossible once. Stranger things have happened in March, and both of these programs are just grateful to be dancing.