Everton vs Manchester United
Monday, 3:00 PM ET | Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool
This is a fascinating Premier League fixture and one that tells you everything about the contrasting trajectories of these two clubs right now. Manchester United at 1.91 are clear favorites to walk into the Hill Dickinson Stadium and collect all three points, while Everton at 3.70 find themselves underdogs in their own brand-new home. The draw at 3.99 reflects just how much the market expects United to control this game. And honestly, given what Michael Carrick has done since taking the reins in January, it's hard to argue with that assessment. Carrick has won four of his five matches in charge, turning a chaotic club reeling from Ruben Amorim's dismissal into a side that looks genuinely organized and dangerous. An 80% win percentage across his two spells in the United dugout is a staggering number.
Everton's season at the Hill Dickinson Stadium has been a mixed bag. Yes, the new ground is spectacular, the 52,888 capacity creates an atmosphere that Goodison Park could only dream of in its later years, and the Toffees historically dominate this fixture at home with 48 wins in 105 meetings on Merseyside. But David Moyes's side slipped to a 1-2 defeat against Bournemouth last time out, and that loss was compounded by Jake O'Brien picking up a red card, meaning the defender is suspended for this one. They're also without Jack Grealish for the remainder of the season after ankle surgery. Sitting 8th on 37 points, Everton have been competitive but inconsistent, and their form reads WDLLW in the last five, which is the kind of run that makes it hard to back them with any real conviction against a team clicking into gear.
Manchester United's transformation under Carrick has been remarkable. The club was in turmoil when Amorim was sacked on January 5 after that extraordinary press conference following the Leeds draw, and Darren Fletcher held the fort briefly before Carrick was officially appointed on January 13 as interim boss until the end of the season. Since then, United have been a different animal. They're sitting 4th on 45 points, which is eight points clear of Everton, and their draw against West Ham last time out was the only blemish in an otherwise dominant stretch. The players clearly respond to Carrick's management style, and there's a cohesion and intensity about this United side that was completely absent under Amorim.
Here's where it gets interesting for the neutrals: the over 2.5 goals carries a 56% probability according to the market, and the most likely scoreline is 1-1. That tells you the bookmakers see a competitive game despite the clear gap in quality between the sides. Everton won the reverse fixture 1-0 earlier this season with Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, who has five league goals this campaign, scoring the winner, so they know they can hurt United. But can they do it without O'Brien in the back line, against a side that has found its rhythm under a new manager? The Hill Dickinson Stadium will be rocking on a Monday night under the lights, and Everton's crowd will try to drag their team through this one, but United's current form and momentum make them a formidable proposition for anyone in the league right now. This has all the ingredients of a proper Premier League battle, and Seamus Coleman's return to the Everton squad adds another interesting dynamic.