The Utah Mammoth visit Vegas for Game 5 with the series tied 2-2 after Shea Theodore's overtime winner at 19:08 of the extra frame on Monday gave the Golden Knights a 5-4 win in Salt Lake City. Vegas is a -164 home favorite for Game 5 with Utah at +136 on the road. The total sits at 5.5 (Over -130, Under +106). Game 4 was the kind of two-comeback playoff thriller that defines the format - Vegas jumped to an early 3-0 lead, Utah responded with four unanswered goals (including two in a 30-second span), the Knights scored to force overtime, and Theodore won it from the point in the dying seconds.
Vegas's structural advantage in the series has been the depth and experience profile that produced their 2023 Stanley Cup. Mitch Marner, who joined Vegas as the marquee July 2025 signing, has been the offensive piece that pushed the Knights' top-six into a different gear, and his series scoring profile has produced the kind of close-game production that has carried the team through tight stretches. Mark Stone's two-way wing minutes have been the matchup constant, and Jack Eichel's faceoff and possession profile has tilted the special-teams battle. Brett Howden's two-goal Game 4 line was the variance moment, and Carter Hart's 27-save line in goal kept the team in the game when the score-line slipped. Adin Hill is expected to be available for Game 5 selection.
Utah's path to retake the series lead is the youth-and-speed identity that head coach Andre Tourigny has built around Logan Cooley, Dylan Guenther, and Clayton Keller. Nick Schmaltz's series scoring profile has been the surprise, and Mikhail Sergachev's three-assist Game 4 line was the structural blue-line piece that pushed the Mammoth to within a single Theodore shot of going up 3-1. Karel Vejmelka's 31-save Game 4 was the kind of goaltending line that has kept the road team in the matchup, and the rookie franchise's first-round series at this stage has produced the kind of underdog energy that has tilted the second period of every game. The road environment in Vegas is the structural challenge - if the Mammoth hold their composure through the first 10 minutes of the T-Mobile Arena buzz, the variance window opens. If they don't, Vegas's home-ice advantage produces the kind of Game 5 lead that the team has historically defended.